Registered Members: 14500 | Current Active Members: 104799

Forum

DID YOU KNOW ?

You can add further comments to your query by clicking on "Add Comment".

This link will appear only, if you are logged-in with your user id and password. The same will appear as

"Querist Comment" on the Forum.

Click here to Post your Query >>
Top 50 Questions UnAnswered Queries

5987 unanswered question(s) — Showing 61–80

Que. Id Date Description
21535 Oct. 26
2025
082701 – (DIRECT TAXES)
A cooprative society is not maintaining proper Fixed assets register but approximate depreciation amount is being debted to profit and loss account. In ITR depreciation debted in added to net profit and Net profit increases As Exact depreciable amount is not available Fixed assets details are not being filled in ITR to get allowable deduction of Depreciation Can Deductionb under sec 80 P be increased to bring taxble profit as nil or tax has to be paid on depreciation amount debted treating alloawable depreciation as nil
BY: Mahesh Kumar
No answers yet View Answers  |  Post Answers
21534 Oct. 25
2025
Commission agent of insurance company_minimum profit – (DIRECT TAXES)
Dear all, Presumptive income scheme is not applicable to commission agent . So what will be the minimum % of profit that should be shown and whether provisions of section 44AB/44AD applicable or not ?? Please throw some light on it ....
BY: SUDIP KUMAR MUKHOPADHYAY
No answers yet View Answers  |  Post Answers
21533 Oct. 15
2025
Place of Supply for online tuition services – (GST)
Firm is engaged in online tuition to students in india and outside india. Its one to one live session only. No recorded classes. Students are charged on hourly basis. Invoices are raised to the address given at the time of registration. Most students are out of india, they are giving address of their present location.Since the most parents are from india they are transferring the fund from their nre a/c or nro a/c.firm is not receiving money in foreign currency. Invoices are raised showing that address and firm is charging IGST at 18%. Such invoices are shown in gstr1 as place of supply other taxable territory (code97).Kindly advise this procedure is correct and for the students address to prove the location whether any other supporting documents to be kept in hand.
BY: JOBIN BABU
No answers yet View Answers  |  Post Answers
21532 Oct. 09
2025
082701 – (GST)
Goods delivered by hand to purchaser value more than Rs 50000- who is from an other ciry in Punjab by Punjab based seller. Eway bill position ?
BY: Mahesh Kumar
No answers yet View Answers  |  Post Answers
21531 Oct. 05
2025
Permission to hold Directorship – (INSOLVENCY)
I am a fellow member and do not hold CoP. I am also an Insolvency Professional (IP) registered with IBBI and IIIPICAI. My other IP colleagues (not all of whom are CA's) along with myself are planning to incorporate an IPE ( as a Pvt. Ltd Co.) where we will be shareholders. I will take up position as an Executive Director in the IPE. Please advise if any prior permission/approval is required from ICAI. If so what are the relevant forms to be submitted and what is the timeframe for getting the approval.
BY: CA. NAIR MANOJ GANGADHARAN
No answers yet View Answers  |  Post Answers
21530 Sep. 30
2025
BAD DEBTS PROVISION AND BAD DEBTS WRITTEN OFF – (DIRECT TAXES)
In Financial year 2023-24 we have provided Rs.2 crores as Doubtful Debts in Bad Debts provision so Profit of the Company reduced by Rs. 2 crores as bad debt provision. In Income Tax that 2 Crores were added back in Profit as it was provision. now in FY 2024-25 we want to claim 2 crores bad debts written off so what is the effect to profit and loss account as without written off in books we can not claim . And if again we are debiting the Profit and loss account then again profit reduced in FY 2024-25.
BY: Arun Kothari
No answers yet View Answers  |  Post Answers
21529 Sep. 29
2025
TAX AUDIT U/S 44AB – (AUDIT)
Turnover exceeding 1cr but does not exceeding 2 cr..whether in will be covered in tax audit 44Ab (limit 60) or 44ad (outside limit of 60 audits)?
BY: SEEMA AGARWAL
No answers yet View Answers  |  Post Answers
21526 Sep. 27
2025
082701 – (GST)
Whether services provided by Unregistered CA like Audit,Tax consultancy and financial consultation will attract RCM
BY: Mahesh Kumar
No answers yet View Answers  |  Post Answers
21527 Sep. 27
2025
082701 – (GST)
A textile prop Firm dealing in Shawl is getting shawl fabricated by sending yarn to Unregistered fabricator. Whether reverse charge is applicable ?
BY: Mahesh Kumar
No answers yet View Answers  |  Post Answers
21528 Sep. 27
2025
082701 – (GST)
If a party issues debit note to somebody for purchase return Whether it should put on portal or the party that has to issue credit note should initiate by uploading Credit note for acceptance
BY: Mahesh Kumar
No answers yet View Answers  |  Post Answers
21525 Sep. 24
2025
Tax audit applicability – (DIRECT TAXES)
I have a client who opted for the presumptive scheme under section 44AD but has declared profit lower than 8%/6%. As a result, tax audit is applicable under section 44AB(e). My query is: Will this tax audit be counted within the limit of 60 tax audits prescribed by ICAI, or will it be excluded from the limit?
BY: BHAVESHKUMAR CHAUDHARY
No answers yet View Answers  |  Post Answers
21524 Sep. 22
2025
GST RATE ON COSMETIC AND PLASTIC SURGERY BY DOCTOR – (GST)
After the 56th GST Council meeting, has there been any change in the GST rate for cosmetic and plastic surgery services provided by doctors, which are currently charged at 18%? Please clarify
BY: PONNUSAMY R
No answers yet View Answers  |  Post Answers
21523 Sep. 10
2025
Charitable & Religious Trust – (DIRECT TAXES)
What is the due date for making investments/deposits u/s 11(5), arising out of receipts of Corpus Donation u/s 11(1)(d). Further, whether the same is to be reported in Form 10.
BY: Nilanjan Kayal
No answers yet View Answers  |  Post Answers
21522 Sep. 09
2025
082701 – (GST)
If we are sending goods within 20 km in Punjab(within a city) by non motorised vehicle, I think E way bill is not required. Am I correct?
BY: Mahesh Kumar
No answers yet View Answers  |  Post Answers
21521 Aug. 29
2025
Under the new ICAI Guidance Note for Non-Corporate Entities, effective from FY 2024–25, the treatmen – (DIRECT TAXES)
Under the new ICAI Guidance Note for Non-Corporate Entities, effective from FY 2024–25, the treatment of personal assets and liabilities in a proprietor’s financial statements Propreitor previously included personal assests and liabilities in his Balance sheet in T Format but now as per New format of Non Corporate entities how should the Propreitor report the personal assests and Liabilities ? Should we Report Personal and Business, Assets and Liabilities separately ?? Or Include it in the Business Balance Sheet or there is any other method Kindly Share as guideance note has not clarified regarding this issue
BY: GOVIND MUNDADA
No answers yet View Answers  |  Post Answers
21520 Aug. 23
2025
APPLICABILITY OF AUDIT UNDER SECTION 44AB – (DIRECT TAXES)
Partnership firm incorporated in the FY-2024-25, having turnover of 5,04,000/- and profit of 18,000/-. Whether tax audit required ?
BY: GAURAV MUNJAL
No answers yet View Answers  |  Post Answers
21519 Aug. 22
2025
TDS u/s 194N - Cash withdrawal from Bank – (DIRECT TAXES)
A client is a cooperative bank. One of their customer ask them to deduct TDS amount from SB A/c instead from cash withdrawal amount. For e.g., if he withdraw Rs,1.2 Cr cash from closure of deposit. TDS amount of Rs,2.4L to be deducted from SB A/c and remit the full amount of Rs,1.2 Cr in cash,
BY: SRIPRIYA PRAKASAM
No answers yet View Answers  |  Post Answers
21518 Aug. 21
2025
PENALTY UNDER SECTION 74 OF GST ACT – (GST)
Our client has received a GST notice under Section 74 of the CGST Act for reversal of input tax credit on purchases made from a bill trader (non-existent dealer). On receipt of the statement in Form DRC-01A, the client has already discharged the tax along with applicable interest and a penalty of 15%, as provided under Section 74(5). However, the Proper Officer is now insisting on payment of 100% penalty. Plz Clarify
BY: PONNUSAMY R
No answers yet View Answers  |  Post Answers
21517 Aug. 19
2025
RCM 9(4) on Payment to Contractor who sends labourers – (GST)
Client a Builder/Developer doing Real estate project under JDA with Land owner.A contractor will send many labourers.Builder pays to contractor and deduct TDS under IT Act 194C.Contractor has no GST.Will this payment to contractor needs to be considered in80:20ratio of mandatory requirement of purchase from regd dealer?If 80% requirement failed, whether liable to RCM 9(4)?If yes,How to avoid RCM for this?
BY: Sivaraman A.R.
No answers yet View Answers  |  Post Answers
21516 Aug. 17
2025
082701 – (Customs & Excise)
We have sent one sample free to canada to a relative by DHL Are we supposed to inform any authority for this in icegate or other
BY: Mahesh Kumar
No answers yet View Answers  |  Post Answers